Home News Why NERSA’s tariff scandal should worry every CFO

Why NERSA’s tariff scandal should worry every CFO

0
Why NERSA’s tariff scandal should worry every CFO

The recent admission by the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (NERSA) that electricity tariffs approved for three metropolitan municipalities and two local municipalities during the 2025/26 financial year were unlawful has exposed a growing vulnerability in the country’s electricity pricing system.

The court ruling, handed down last week, has revealed a concerning trend of inaccurate electricity tariffs among multiple local municipalities – an issue that’s not only confined to the municipalities involved in this case. The greatest threat to profitability, it seems, is not just rising electricity tariffs, but the possibility that energy-intensive businesses are paying more than they should in the first place.

This raises a fundamental question for businesses already grappling with escalating operating costs: if regulatory approval cannot guarantee the validity of electricity tariffs, how confident can businesses be that their electricity accounts are accurate?

The growing cost of getting it wrong

Electricity has become one of the most significant operating expenses for South African businesses, particularly in manufacturing, mining, agriculture and other energy-intensive sectors.

While successive tariff increases have placed considerable pressure on profitability, inaccurate or inflated billing introduces another layer of financial exposure that can erode margins, either very suddenly or more quietly over time.

The scale of this risk was illustrated by last week’s court proceedings, where it emerged that businesses in Nelson Mandela Bay paid 76% more for electricity than it cost the municipality to provide the service during the previous financial year.

Although the 1) legality of a tariff and 2) the accuracy of an individual electricity account are distinct issues, both emphasise the importance of independent scrutiny.

1)     Tariff relief may be possible, but electricity billing is inherently complex. The governance process includes consultants calculating the proposed tariff increases, which are often accepted without sufficient scrutiny because the national regulator lacks the resources to review them beyond the municipality’s standard tariff increase. If municipal tariff restructuring brings about an 18% cost increase instead of the 8% initially applied for, there is no body currently running simulation analysis on the actual cost increase for the consumers. 

2)     Charges vary according to tariff classifications, consumption patterns, maximum demand, time-of-use structures and municipal billing methodologies. Incorrect tariff allocations, inaccurate meter readings or misapplied charges can result in businesses paying substantially more than they should.

For a large industrial operation consuming millions of rands in electricity annually, even a relatively small discrepancy can translate into significant financial losses.

Affected Municipalities: NERSA admitted errors in tariffs for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Nelson Mandela Bay, Emfuleni, and Madibeng.

A changing energy market adds complexity

With the emergence of electricity wheeling, the financial management of electricity is becoming considerably more complex, creating both increasing opportunity and risk for local businesses.

Wheeling, which enables businesses to purchase electricity from independent producers using existing transmission and distribution networks, offers opportunities to secure competitively priced renewable energy through long-term power purchase agreements.

However, the commercial benefits are not necessarily straightforward. Businesses must account for network charges, Use of System distribution and transmission fees, electricity purchased from utilities when contracted generation is insufficient, and the costs of balancing supply with actual consumption.

For large energy consumers, accurately reconciling these multiple charges and supply arrangements is critical to determining whether alternative energy procurement strategies are delivering their intended financial benefits.

From operational expense to financial risk

Historically, businesses have largely managed electricity as an unavoidable operational cost, focusing on reducing consumption and improving energy efficiency.

However, businesses now need to move beyond monitoring consumption towards independently verifying the financial accuracy of their energy accounts, as this cost carries greater impact on financial performance. Unexpected municipal charges, for example, can emerge after year-end, undermining the accuracy of financial statements and potentially affecting a company’s share price.

This financial oversight must also extend beyond municipal accounts to include on-site generation performance, wheeling reconciliation, curtailment exposure and renewable energy credit compliance across every active power purchase agreement in real time.

For organisations operating across multiple sites or municipalities, this becomes particularly important, as differing tariff structures and billing practices make this especially challenging. Without independent verification, undetected discrepancies leave businesses exposed to unnecessary costs and financial risk.

R840 million already recovered across just 373 billing claims

Businesses increasingly need systems capable of independently modelling electricity costs, reconciling multiple data sources and identifying discrepancies, ensuring provisions and accruals are provided for before they develop into costly disputes.

Mila Vicquery, General Manager of Syntiro and Head of Sustainability at Energy Partners

Energy Partners’ South African-developed Syntiro was designed to provide this oversight by modelling tariff structures and cost exposure, reconciling billing information and consolidating energy data into a single, audit-ready view.

Through Syntiro, organisations have recovered around R840 million in disputed energy charges across 373 billing claims, the largest of these valued at R28 million.

Ultimately, NERSA’s recent admission should serve as a wake-up call for corporate South Africa. As the electricity market becomes increasingly decentralised and complex, businesses can no longer afford to manage only how much electricity they consume. They must also take back control of billing and tariff accuracy.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here